Attorney Commentary

You Told Your Boss You're Pregnant. Suddenly, Everything at Work Changed.

By Shelley Bryant — California Employment Attorney
Published

Did your employer cut your hours, criticize your work, or fire you after learning you're pregnant? California employment attorney Shelley Bryant explains what to do.

You told your manager you were expecting. A week later, your schedule was cut. A month later, you received your first performance write-up in three years.

Before you announced your pregnancy, everything seemed fine. Your supervisor praised your work. You received good performance evaluations. Nobody suggested your job was in jeopardy.

Now your manager is questioning everything you do. You're being excluded from meetings. Assignments you used to handle are going to other employees.

You're beginning to wonder: Is this a coincidence, or is my employer trying to get rid of me because I'm pregnant?

I've represented California employees since 2002, and I've dealt with situations like these hundreds of times.

One of the first things I want to know is simple: What changed after your employer learned you were pregnant?

Pregnancy Discrimination Doesn't Always Start With Getting Fired

Most employers know they cannot legally fire someone because she's pregnant. So when discrimination happens, the employer usually gives a different reason.

An employee who received positive evaluations for years is suddenly accused of poor performance.

A supervisor who previously praised her work begins documenting minor mistakes.

Overtime she used to work regularly starts disappearing.

Or management announces a restructuring, and somehow the pregnant employee is the one whose position gets eliminated.

Any one of these things might have a legitimate explanation.

But when these changes begin shortly after an employer learns about a pregnancy, I want to know why.

And I want to see the evidence.

These Things Really Happen

Consider Tiffany Jackson, a San Diego employee who sued her employer in 2016 after allegedly being fired less than two hours after announcing her pregnancy.

According to an ABC 10 News report, Jackson said she had received only positive feedback about her work. Shortly after she shared her news, she was told she was not a good fit.

Her employer disputed her allegations. It said the termination decision had been made and documented before Jackson disclosed her pregnancy.

That's the real question in many of these cases: When did the employer actually decide?

In a case like this, I want to see the documents the employer says prove its timing. Who prepared them? When were they created, and have they been changed since? Who received them? Is there an earlier email discussing the decision, or isn't there?

Video: "ABC 10 News — Tiffany Jackson's Pregnancy Discrimination Lawsuit" (ABC 10 News, YouTube). Watch on YouTubePlaying this video loads it from YouTube, which may set cookies.Bryant Workers Law is not affiliated with the video's creators or the people who appear in it.

In another San Diego case, former AutoZone store manager Rosario Juarez said her treatment changed after she became pregnant. According to news reports, her workload increased, she was criticized even though she was meeting her sales targets, she was demoted, and, after she filed a complaint with the state, she was fired.

A jury awarded substantial damages. The case was later dismissed by agreement while on appeal, and the final terms were not publicly disclosed.

What interests me isn't the headline-grabbing verdict. It's the evidence. When a manager is criticized while hitting her numbers, I want the sales records, the records of other store managers, and proof of whether everyone was held to the same standard.

What Your Employer Says Isn't Necessarily What Happened

When employees contact me, they often repeat the explanation their employer gave them.

"My manager says I'm not meeting expectations."

"HR says my position was eliminated."

"They told me the company is restructuring."

Sometimes those explanations are accurate.

But an employer's explanation is not the end of the investigation. It's the beginning.

Employers tend to defend these cases the same few ways: a paper trail of performance problems, a restructuring, or a decision supposedly made before anyone knew about the pregnancy. My job is to find out whether that explanation holds up.

The Evidence Your Employer Doesn't Expect You to See

Employees know what their supervisors said to them. They usually don't know what those supervisors said privately, to HR and to each other.

Your employer isn't likely to voluntarily hand over the private emails and text messages its managers exchanged about you. But in litigation, we can demand relevant records, subject to applicable legal protections, question the people involved under oath, and compare their explanations with what the documents actually show.

Depending on the claims and circumstances, that may include:

Emails and texts between supervisors and HR. What did your manager say after learning you were pregnant? Did anyone worry about your leave or suggest replacing you? When did HR first hear about "performance problems"?

Performance and disciplinary records. When did the write-ups begin, and who asked for them? Did the company follow its own discipline policy?

HR investigation files. If you complained about discrimination, who did HR interview? What did it review? What did it leave out?

Records involving other employees. How were employees who weren't pregnant treated when they made similar mistakes or requested time off? Who replaced you?

Depositions of the decision-makers. Under oath, your supervisor, the HR manager, and whoever made the final decision can be questioned about when and why they acted. Their answers can be compared with the documents and with each other.

I also look for changes in the employer's story. If the company first said your position was eliminated and later says you were fired for poor performance, I want to know why.

A shifting explanation doesn't automatically prove discrimination, but it is often one of the most important things I find.

Sometimes the Evidence Is Right There in a Text Message

In 2018, a young employee at a Jersey Mike's restaurant in Washington state reported that she was dropped from the work schedule after telling her manager she was pregnant.

When she asked about her schedule, the manager texted that it wasn't going to work out and that her upcoming maternity leave was a problem.

According to CBS News, the franchise owner said it never should have happened, and the manager resigned.

Most cases don't come with a text like that. More often, the evidence is pieced together from timing, the employer's records, witness testimony, and inconsistent explanations.

So don't assume you have no case just because your supervisor never openly admitted it.

What Does California Law Say?

California's Fair Employment and Housing Act generally prohibits employers with five or more employees from discriminating because of pregnancy, childbirth, breastfeeding, or related medical conditions.

That includes firing, demoting, or cutting hours because of pregnancy. California also protects pregnancy-related accommodations and leave.

But being pregnant doesn't mean an employer can never discipline or terminate you.

The question is whether pregnancy was a substantial motivating reason for the decision.

And that is often a question of evidence.

What Should You Do If This Is Happening to You?

First, document what changed. Write down when you announced your pregnancy, who you told, and what changed afterward: schedule, assignments, evaluations, treatment.

Second, preserve records you are lawfully entitled to keep. Save your own evaluations and communications. Don't improperly access company systems or take confidential documents.

Third, be careful about resigning or signing agreements. A severance agreement may require you to give up legal claims. Have it reviewed first.

Finally, don't wait until you're fired to get advice. The time to evaluate what's happening is often while you're still working.

I've Seen This Before. Call Me If It's Happening to You.

I've represented California employees since 2002.

I've handled hundreds of employment disputes involving discrimination, retaliation, and other unlawful treatment.

I know how employers defend these cases, because I've heard their explanations many times. And I know how to investigate what actually happened, using the emails, records, and testimony employees usually can't get on their own.

If your employer started treating you differently after learning you were pregnant, don't assume there's nothing you can do.

Maybe your hours were reduced.

Maybe your supervisor suddenly began criticizing your work.

Maybe you were passed over for a promotion, pushed out of your position, or fired.

If this sounds familiar, contact us for a free, confidential case evaluation. Let's talk about what happened.

Shelley Bryant Bryant Workers Law 559-985-0440

We represent employees throughout California.

Have questions about your situation?

Bryant Workers Law represents California employees. Contact us for a free, confidential case evaluation.

Free Case Evaluation
Shelley Bryant, California Employment Attorney

About the Author

Shelley Bryant

California Employment Attorney

Shelley Bryant is a California employment attorney who represents employees only. Mr. Bryant has personally filed and litigated employment lawsuits in 19 California counties. He earned his law degree from the University of California, Davis School of Law.

About Shelley Bryant

Disclaimer: This article provides general legal information about California employment law. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change; verify current law before relying on this information. Every case is different. Consult an attorney for advice about your specific situation.